{ "source_revision": "4d09ba6d6a7e891dd8063974dfe81b3d78e3494f", "compute": { "ssh_alias": "", "hostname": "", "gpu": "NVIDIA GB10", "qwen_revision": "2fc06364715b967f1860aea9cf38778875588b17", "qwen_p50c_original_patch_hashes": "verified using the authors' unchanged apply_edit.py; this is artifact validation, not a fresh editing run" }, "experiments": [ { "experiment": 1, "fresh_prompt_runs": { "exp1_which_game/runs/breakout": "completed", "exp1_which_game/runs/freeway": "completed", "exp1_which_game/runs/pacman": "completed", "exp1_which_game/runs/pong": "completed" }, "original_inputs": "available", "evaluation": "Published answer key available; original automated scorer is not included.", "status": "fresh_prompt_stage_completed; labels_compared_with_published_key" }, { "experiment": 2, "fresh_prompt_runs": { "exp2_diffusion/runs/circle": "completed", "exp2_diffusion/runs/square": "completed", "exp2_diffusion/runs/triangle": "completed" }, "original_inputs": "available", "evaluation": "Published answer key available; original automated scorer is not included.", "status": "fresh_prompt_stage_completed; labels_compared_with_published_key" }, { "experiment": 3, "status": "all_six_fresh_conversations_completed; independent_audit_passed", "available": "All six initial prompts and all three blocks.npz archives.", "missing": [ "Original Python-analysis harness/driver with W loading, sandbox setup, feedback formatting and final-answer scoring.", "Original Python/library versions are not pinned." ], "result_path": "reconstructed-exp3/", "first_result": { "case": "python_r0", "corpus_correct": true, "order_correct": true, "copy_heads_exact": true, "python_runs": 10 }, "completed_results": { "completed": 6, "corpus_correct": 3, "order_correct": 6, "copy_heads_exact": 5, "python_runs": 50, "cli_turns": 56, "all_code_manually_approved": true, "independent_audit": "passed 723 artifact hashes, all prompts/feedback/context, execution/review chains and independent score recomputation" } }, { "experiment": 4, "fresh_prompt_runs": { "exp4_fix_car/runs/oneshot_repair/reply": "completed" }, "missing": [ "Original edit parser and rounded-network reconstruction implementation.", "Original weightenv/lmo/env.py evaluation wrapper and search/test RNG streams. Kinetix itself and the checkpoint-to-actor naming map are available." ], "status": "fresh_policy_evaluation_completed_with_reconstructed_harness", "available": "Original PPO and edited-actor checkpoints verified; exact Kinetix commit 80ee9c292837c825cafaf9889323fdcc212efd1b fetched. JAX 0.4.38 recorded; original logs indicate Python 3.10.", "result_path": "reconstructed-exp4/results.json", "evaluation_episodes": 3840, "audit": "independent episode, aggregate, tensor, source and seed audit passed" }, { "experiment": 5, "fresh_prompt_runs": { "exp5_write_from_scratch/runs/asterix/reply": "completed", "exp5_write_from_scratch/runs/breakout/reply": "completed", "exp5_write_from_scratch/runs/seaquest/reply": "completed" }, "missing": [ "Original edit parser and MinAtar evaluation driver, including RNG/reset conventions.", "Original PPO baseline checkpoints and training/evaluation implementation, if reproducing the published PPO comparisons. Fresh written policies start at zero." ], "note": "Use released game weights. Original missing PPO baseline checkpoints will not be reconstructed by training; no exact missing-baseline result is claimed.", "status": "written_policy_evaluation_complete; optional_PPO_retraining_cancelled_by_user", "available": "Three original hand.npz policies verified. MinAtar 1.0.15 wheel hash verified and each game source file matches the source embedded in the original prompts byte-for-byte.", "result_path": "reconstructed-exp5/summary.json", "evaluation_episodes": 6000, "audit": "independent episode, aggregate, tensor, source and seed audit passed", "reconstructed_ppo_baselines": { "status": "cancelled_before_launch_by_user", "planned_runs": 32, "planned_nominal_environment_steps": 6800000000, "feasibility_report": "exp5-ppo-feasibility/feasibility.json", "launch_gate": "No launch authorized: user excluded game-network retraining.", "provenance": "New reconstruction using fixed published recipe plus explicitly documented missing CleanRL-style defaults; not author checkpoint bytes", "runtime_estimate_status": "Actual trainer pinned to four3.9GHz cores5\u20138 measured83.5k/68.1k/82.2k aggregate steps/s (Breakout/Seaquest/Asterix), projecting24.1h ideal wall time.24\u201348h is planning range, not guarantee; unpinned195h serial sample reflects heterogeneous CPU placement.", "planning_wall_hours": [ 24, 48 ], "planned_cpu_affinity": [ 5, 6, 7, 8 ], "actual_environment_steps": 6799982592, "startup_review": "exp5-ppo-feasibility/startup-review.json", "plan_sha256": "7750dc4fa3522386e46be40259ffb67c7cd8b8cb1c8dae1e585e9f15622811b3", "cancellation_record": "exp5-ppo-feasibility/cancelled-before-launch.json" } }, { "experiment": 6, "status": "all_four_writer_budgets_and_48000_heldout_game_records_complete_and_audited_with_disclosed_substitute_opponents", "missing": [ "scripts/gohand/play.py and its Go environment/opponent dependencies.", "Original writer loop, pass execution server, positions/games tools and evaluator.", "Original small PPO/REINFORCE practice and hidden-opponent checkpoints.", "Same-size PPO baseline training implementation, if retraining baselines is part of the replication." ], "available": "Initial prompts, original Go Python sandbox, final written networks and three same-size PPO checkpoints.", "practice_opponent_deviation": "Strong uses released same-size PPO seed1; weak uses a per-action equal mixture of that policy and uniform legal moves. Seeds0/2 remain held out. The opponent description will be corrected in prompts and the diff retained.", "completed_writer_budgets": [ 0, 10, 25, 50 ], "planned_scoring_games_per_budget": 12000, "budget_0_results": { "fresh_main_win_rate": 0.195, "released_control_main_win_rate": 0.40275, "fresh_random_win_rate": 0.941, "released_control_random_win_rate": 0.997, "games": 12000, "independent_audit": "passed all episode/aggregate/hash consistency checks; engine rule tests separately passed" }, "budget_10_writer": { "cli_turns": 28, "python_runs": 17, "passes": 10, "all_code_manually_reviewed": true, "final_answer_sha256": "e93a1f25d900cf73e7c8a65d4765afc64c6d289b1aea2c852a1b0dd8f5202980", "heldout_scoring": "completed; 12000games independently audited" }, "completed_evaluation_budgets": [ 0, 10, 25, 50 ], "budget_10_results": { "fresh_main_win_rate": 0.69375, "released_control_main_win_rate": 0.49825, "fresh_minus_control": 0.1955, "fresh_random_win_rate": 0.9995, "released_control_random_win_rate": 0.996, "games": 12000, "independent_audit": "passed all episode/aggregate/hash consistency checks; no second-engine replay claimed" }, "budget_25_writer": { "cli_turns": 55, "python_runs": 29, "passes": 25, "all_code_manually_reviewed": true, "final_answer_sha256": "d45d07576a17176b32bbe6af086d168f9a9d453df28b6284b0b3a7d0bacc5c65", "heldout_scoring": "completed; 12000 games independently audited" }, "budget_25_results": { "fresh_main_win_rate": 0.6975, "released_control_main_win_rate": 0.4795, "fresh_minus_control": 0.218, "fresh_random_win_rate": 0.997, "released_control_random_win_rate": 0.991, "games": 12000, "independent_audit": "passed all episode/aggregate/hash consistency checks; no second-engine replay claimed" }, "budget_50_writer": { "cli_turns": 92, "python_runs": 41, "passes": 50, "all_code_manually_reviewed": true, "final_answer_sha256": "42961ff9c8083fa6caa79e0202a5863fd9026c0bae8de7bc361035ad3e4086c0", "heldout_scoring": "completed; all 12000 game records and 2425 writer artifact hashes independently audited; three final tensor copies match" }, "budget_50_results": { "fresh_main_win_rate": 0.85125, "released_control_main_win_rate": 0.77225, "fresh_minus_control": 0.079, "fresh_random_win_rate": 0.9975, "released_control_random_win_rate": 0.9995, "games": 12000, "independent_audit": "passed all episode/aggregate/hash consistency checks; no second-engine replay claimed" }, "audit": "All four writer transcripts and frozen policies verified; 48000 held-out game records independently audited. Original small PPO/REINFORCE opponents remain unavailable and substituted." }, { "experiment": 7, "status": "checkpoint_reconstruction_complete; ten_of_fifteen_readers_audited; remaining_readers_wait_for_Codex_account_allowance", "missing": [ "Six original honest/sycophantic Gemma checkpoints matching models.sha256, plus the matching A/B releases/tokenizers/configs.", "Original weights-only/attention harness, attention server, judgment scorer and causal-patching evaluator." ], "note": "New fine-tunes from unchanged author scripts; original checkpoints absent. All artifacts audited. Wrong-answer preference is teacher-forced sequence logprob comparison, not free-generation accuracy.", "base_revision": "ac82b4e820549b854eebf28ce6dedaf9fdfa17b3", "result_path": "reconstructed-exp7/README.md", "honest_wrong_preference_known_heldout": [ 0.020833333333333332, 0, 0.03424657534246575 ], "sycophant_wrong_preference_known_heldout": [ 1, 1, 1 ], "reader_partial": { "completed": 10, "total": 15, "rounds": { "weights_only_1": { "completed": 3, "total": 3, "correct": 1, "forced_ties": 3, "mean_p_correct": 0.5 }, "weights_only_2": { "completed": 1, "total": 3, "correct": 1, "forced_ties": 1, "mean_p_correct": 0.5 }, "weights_only_3": { "completed": 2, "total": 3, "correct": 1, "forced_ties": 2, "mean_p_correct": 0.5 }, "weights_only_4": { "completed": 1, "total": 3, "correct": 0, "forced_ties": 0, "mean_p_correct": 0.48 }, "attention_tool": { "completed": 3, "total": 3, "correct": 3, "forced_ties": 0, "mean_p_correct": 0.89 } }, "interpretation": "Six weights-only choices at p_A=.5 are forced ties; the seventh is an incorrect near-chance choice at p_A=.52. Components remain hypotheses pending causal evaluation.", "independent_audit": { "passed": true, "completed_audited": 10, "turns": 188, "python_runs": 126, "attention_calls": 12, "attention_arrays": 384, "python_errors_preserved": 3, "truncations_preserved": 8, "scores_sha256": "1194f838811fba7d7a45ceb5cbb4ca174cf0111eb3eb71f7d1c5a7d0a7054651" }, "scheduling": "Account usage exhausted. Original driver74929 suspended at retained approved t030 before execution; spare recovery stopped on usage rejection. Preserve existing states; no retraining of game networks after reader completion." }, "causal_baselines": { "pairs": 3, "models": 6, "fact_records": 878, "author_exact_candidate_comparisons": 36, "candidate_parity_scope": "First3facts per model,2candidate answers each; max error0.", "independent_copied_record_audit": "passed", "selection_dependent_patches_run": 0 } }, { "experiment": 8, "status": "editors_stopped_after_first_passes: p10c_provider_rejection, p25c_and_g05b_account_usage_limit; Gemma_benchmark_campaign_running; first_Qwen64_shard_launched", "missing": [ "Original persistent Python kernel and save_edit validation implementation.", "Original forward-pass server, activation/attention extraction helpers, and editor driver with handoff/notice behavior.", "Missing imported IFEval and multiple-choice grading modules and benchmark preparation dependencies.", "Original package/container versions and evaluation RNG/sharding details." ], "available": "Qwen base revision, original prompts/practice sets, saved edit archives, reconstruction and partial evaluation code.", "includes": "Qwen 10/25/50-pass runs and Gemma follow-up 5/10/25/50-pass runs.", "gemma_followup_access": "Resolved; pinned base downloaded to Spark.", "gpqa_access": { "status": "resolved_from_author_published_archive; no_user_action_required", "author_repository": "https://github.com/idavidrein/gpqa", "author_revision": "56686c06f5e19865c153de0fdb11be3890014df7", "hf_revision": "83022cefff930aea54f654c0b282e74b9eeda5c6", "filename": "gpqa_diamond.csv", "sha256": "41d1213cd7a4998605a26c2798500652572007161b3a92817ba46b35befcd305", "matches_hf_git_blob": true, "rows": 198, "bytes": 1373492, "deviation": "Original option permutation was unpublished; deterministic per-ID shuffle reconstructed." }, "heldout_preparation": { "available_sets": 10, "gpqa": "complete; official author bytes verified against pinned HF blob", "normalized_practice_overlaps": { "mmlupro1k": 3, "other_nine_sets": 0 }, "overlap_policy": "retain published set membership; report overlaps", "startup_review": "passed9benchmark scripts/15runtime scripts,10datasets,7control models,48official tests/541IFEval configurations" }, "published_controls": { "rebuilt": 7, "all_edited_tensor_hashes_match_archive": true, "all_unedited_tensors_match_pinned_base": true, "scoring": "Ready Gemma campaign launched and queued; no new control shard started at12:27:10UTC. Qwen controls await capacity/startup review." }, "runtime_snapshot": { "observed_at_utc": "2026-11-03T12:09:28Z", "case": "p10c", "completed_passes": 1, "total_pass_budget": 10, "completed_generations": 256, "activation_samples_completed": 256, "activation_samples_total": 256, "total_forward_wall_seconds": 13618.261, "generation_worker_wall_seconds": 10687.33, "practice_baseline_correct": 33, "practice_baseline_total": 256, "correct_by_source": { "gsm8k": { "correct": 22, "total": 128 }, "math": { "correct": 11, "total": 128 } }, "output_tokens": 7495295, "reached_token_cap": 224, "sampling_unchanged": true, "audit": "all256 sample/seed/token/grade/tokenizer records and54788096 finite activation values checked; root result review passed", "audit_path": "reconstructed-exp8/forward-audits/p10c-r001/root-review.json", "scope": "Unedited practice baseline; not final edited held-out performance" }, "prospective_throughput_change": { "status": "both actual64sequence capacity checks passed root review; only firstQwen64benchmark shard launched; no v2editors launched", "plan": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/PLAN.txt", "review": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/independent-plan-review.json", "profile_sha256": "93faf4cd7d27ef0231e7bf41d665f12b9cda9025ab27a5f026a65b7034986322", "max_num_seqs_candidate": 64, "applicability": "Untouched Qwen p50c and unstarted Qwen heldout families; Gemma editors require separate measured-capacity review; all Gemma heldout partitions remain 32 answers", "active_cases_unchanged": [ "p10c", "p25c", "g05b" ], "old_total_shards": 3492, "candidate_total_shards": 2092, "planned_answers_unchanged": 110910, "speedup_measured": false, "independent_partition_groups_verified": 612, "source_commit": "e5de714", "cpu_tests": { "runtime_recovery": 26, "benchmark_durability": 14 }, "source_review": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/implementation/followup-404dca3/independent-source-review.json", "production_source_commit": "7e0b6c8c217a8b425bc908eca0523ed2e8c3d635", "deployment_review": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/deployment-7e0b6c8/independent-deployment-review.json", "capacity_approval": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/deployment-7e0b6c8/capacity-startup-review.json", "runtime_source_identity_sha256": "aaed712c22d05000d8a437b709e7b8a60f97fe7a0892916cfa86aa7e2e44b918", "benchmark_context_sha256": "f98539a3d602df0cbc145a83604d22cb5001b1bc93af67dcd8eb9dfe7d64c706", "capacity_check": { "queued_at_utc": "2026-11-03T10:50:15Z", "launcher_pid": 723796, "utility_pid": 723797, "state": "completed_and_root_reviewed", "generated_answers": 0, "measured_context": 34816, "measured_cache_concurrency": 95.4776119402985, "root_review": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/capacity-results/qwen/root-review.json" }, "jsonl_correction": { "status": "independent source review and exact deployment verification passed; deployed to unstarted v2 benchmark and separate auditor", "source_commit": "34bb59778b1ea50e4159d2aeed35c73fb9e20c13", "affected": "Unstarted v2 benchmark evaluate/aggregate and s64 audit readers split U+2028 inside one valid GPQA JSON string. Frozen v1 benchmark and current experiments are unaffected.", "data_unchanged": true, "grouping_unchanged": true, "deployment_review": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/jsonl-correction/root-deployment-review.json", "auditor_sha256": "511000284d11a1559950ba3c8e305d4282f781cbb9939cfab98ffed6e054001d" }, "gemma_capacity_check": { "queued_at_utc": "2026-11-03T12:14:56Z", "launcher_pid": 812585, "state": "completed_and_root_reviewed", "generated_answers": 0, "startup_review": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/gemma-capacity-request/startup-review.json", "measured_context": 10240, "measured_cache_concurrency": 271.2109955423477, "root_review": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/capacity-results/gemma/root-review.json" } }, "host_capacity_snapshot": { "observed_at_utc": "2026-11-03T10:56:00Z", "time_precision": "approximately one minute", "memory_available_gib": 52, "disk_available_tib": 1.2, "cpu_idle_percent": 95, "io_wait_percent": 0, "swap_used_gib": 3.4, "current_swap_in_out": 0, "bottleneck": "GPU decoding of long sequences; no observed CPU, I/O, active swapping or capacity bottleneck" }, "gpu_snapshot": { "observed_at_utc": "2026-11-03T10:56:00Z", "time_precision": "approximately one minute", "gpu_utilization_percent": 94, "gpu_clock_mhz": 2405, "gpu_temperature_c": 55 }, "artifact_auditors": { "generation_forward": { "source": "reconstructed-exp8/forward-audit-preparation/jsonl-correction/audit_exp8_forward.py", "sha256": "480cdc179f962eaa246f21f8766da2f23acb9c073fb7ca595705689fbb1d1065", "root_review": "reconstructed-exp8/forward-audit-preparation/jsonl-correction/independent-review.json", "status": "physical JSONL parser correction approved; six tests passed; actual first forward passed. Old failed audit/source retained." }, "qwen_64_shard": { "source": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/audit-preparation/audit_exp8_s64_shard.py", "sha256": "625a80bb96e9bd9b9170727376f316cef45f933772eefc4b986c15ccb1c22265", "root_review": "reconstructed-exp8/performance-assessment/proposed-v2/audit-preparation/independent-helper-review.json", "status": "reviewed; six tests independently passed; no actual new-profile scientific shard yet" } }, "first_heldout_shard": { "profile": "gemma", "variant": "base-gemma", "set": "math500", "shard": "0/63", "problems": 8, "answers": 32, "strict_correct": 0, "lenient_correct": 1, "normal_stop": 30, "token_limit_stop": 2, "output_tokens": 53954, "worker_wall_seconds": 90.962, "root_review": "reconstructed-exp8/benchmark-first-shard/base-gemma-math500-s0of63/root-review.json", "status": "actual records and tokenizer/frozen-grader replay passed; root independently verified all32 records and exact frozen source/model/context bindings", "scope": "One fixed shard only, not a full MATH500 score" }, "ready_gemma_campaign": { "status": "running independently of Codex account usage", "ready_variants": 5, "total_shards": 398, "completed_shards": 53, "remaining_shards": 345, "total_answers": 12638, "grouping": "unchanged v1, at most32 answers; base MATH500+GSM8K and four published-control MATH500 families", "manifest_sha256": "0c925edf512aaef66a95320f20484dddf08086b0851724f463e97dede321c19a", "review_request": "reconstructed-exp8/gemma-campaign-preparation/review-request.json", "remaining_answers": 12606, "startup_review": "reconstructed-exp8/gemma-campaign-preparation/startup-review.json", "startup_review_sha256": "eb4e0600f26de217946c74104d72932e2308035934cec15d9415fb02c67ee3db", "launched_utc": "2026-11-03T12:26:40.526488+00:00", "dispatcher_pid": 819739, "new_started_shards_at_122710_utc": 0, "root_launch_review": "reconstructed-exp8/gemma-campaign-preparation/root-launch-review.json", "completed_answers": 1696, "progress_observation_utc": "2026-11-03T15:49:00Z", "observation_time_precision": "approximate read-only snapshot" }, "editor_failure": { "case": "p10c", "failed_turn": "t008", "failed_at_utc": "2026-11-03T12:24:14Z", "cause": "Codex provider rejected the prompt as potentially violating usage policy; no specific reason supplied", "returncode": 1, "answer_returned": false, "committed_turn": 7, "completed_passes": 1, "total_pass_budget": 10, "valid_context_audit": true, "retry_or_prompt_change": false, "artifacts": "reconstructed-exp8/runs/p10c/turns/t008/", "effect": "No final edited checkpoint or full ten-pass result; first practice baseline remains valid. Other cases and benchmark campaign continue.", "failure_captured_utc": "2026-11-03T12:33:53.003412+00:00", "preservation_review": "reconstructed-exp8/incidents/p10c-t008-provider-refusal/root-review.json", "preservation_scope": "Original failed turn and actual rollout verified; all20remote scratch/queue source and snapshot files match; no in-memory serialization or recovery attempted." }, "active_generation_snapshot": { "observed_at_utc": "2026-11-03T12:38:09Z", "case": "p25c", "generated_answers": 41, "requested_answers": 128, "latest_completion_progress_elapsed_seconds": 1728, "worker_elapsed_seconds": 1856, "engine_sample_utc": "2026-11-03T12:38:01Z", "engine_output_tokens_per_second": 886.3, "running_sequences": 32, "waiting_sequences": 55, "kv_cache_percent": 11.6, "scope": "Historical progress snapshot, not completed forward result; timestamps for different measurements are separate." }, "ready_qwen_preparation": { "status": "first base MATH5000/32 approved and launched; wider824job campaign awaits first64audit and concrete manifest approval", "ready_variants": [ "base-qwen", "published-p10c", "published-p25c", "published-p50c" ], "planned_shards": 824, "planned_answers": 51584, "first_shard": "base-qwen MATH5000/32,16questions x4samples=64answers", "review": "reconstructed-exp8/qwen-campaign-preparation/independent-review.json", "review_sha256": "1e5a8180be74349a4074019076ac060cc7be4f1694fa5c2affb3318ecf56215f", "remaining_gates": [ "Successful actual Qwen capacity report and independent root review are absent.", "Final immutable per-variant startup reviews are absent; this preparation cannot authorize execution.", "First64 actual records, consumed token IDs and record audit await inference; wider dispatcher implementation/testing and campaign approval remain separate." ], "fresh_p10": "unavailable; excluded without substituting base", "dispatcher_source": { "source_commit": "8f42bf5d8d8535a15de9b8a472046b711211016e", "integration_commit": "5572643723c03307800ad37766081b9943f2b3bc", "status": "independent and root source review passed; exact code-only deployment approved; no campaign launch", "root_review": "reconstructed-exp8/qwen-campaign-preparation/implementation/root-source-review.json" }, "context_scan": { "problems": 4604, "groups": 206, "greater_than_34816_groups": 17, "greater_than_34816_jobs_in_ready_four": 68, "max_context": { "mmlupro1k": 35298, "gpqa": 35572, "other_eight_sets": 34816 }, "scope": "Exact CPU rendering/tokenization only; actual engine capacity checks still required for every job." }, "first_shard_launch": { "launched_utc": "2026-11-03T15:48:16.145793+00:00", "evaluator_pid": 1041973, "exec_session_id": 48182, "review_sha256": "16b9acb996b988c496496cf4a746d9cb7ccc13c72dcc131a33253b8b6664f014", "evidence": "reconstructed-exp8/qwen-campaign-preparation/first-shard-launch/" } }, "account_usage_block": { "cases": [ "p25c", "g05b" ], "evidence": "usage-limit-2026-11-03/manifest.json", "new_answers_from_failed_turns": 0, "reported_reset": "Nov 4th, 2026 9:30 AM (verbatim CLI text; timezone not specified by error)", "retries_attempted": false }, "completed_practice_requests_pending_independent_audit": { "p25c": { "request": "r001", "answers": 128, "correct": 12, "passes": 1, "budget": 25 }, "g05b": { "request": "r002", "answers": 2048, "correct": 337, "passes": 1, "budget": 5 } } } ], "overall_status": "experiments1_6_complete_with_documented_limits_and_no_missing_PPO_retraining; experiment7_remaining_readers_blocked_by_usage; experiment8_gpu_benchmarks_running_editors_stopped", "artifact_policy": "Reconstruction of missing non-game artifacts remains authorized. User now excludes training game networks from scratch; reuse released game weights.", "fresh_responses_completed": 11, "fresh_response_audits_passed": 11, "source_artifact_hashes_verified": 1387, "exp4_exp5_artifact_audit": "exp4-exp5-originals/artifact-manifest.json", "artifact_policy_updated_at": "2026-11-02T23:04:34.234196-08:00", "updated_at": "2026-11-03T15:50:47.429687+00:00", "reproduction_bundle": { "guide": "REPRODUCE.txt", "source_zip": "reproduction-source.zip", "sha256": "e4fed4e8757b7096b4f04af815cb467d173aaafe5d898a9a923c91c039c6ed13", "source_commit": "66f3553f358dfeace0421ff851d2eb3ad5edf765", "independent_package_review": "passed all239members,177Git files,14bootstrap,4archivedruntime,17new and25retainedmetadata comparisons; corrected auditors/campaign bindings and retained previous archive verified", "snapshot_only": "Experiments still running; environment and data provisioning required.", "run_state_note": "Guide contains historical active-case wording from before the p10c provider rejection was identified. Current status/results supersede its run-state snapshot; source hashes remain valid.", "pending_refresh": "New independently reviewed Qwen dispatcher5572643 will be added in the next source snapshot; existing66f3553 package remains a verified historical snapshot." }, "completed_evaluation_figure": { "png": "audited-evaluations.png", "pdf": "audited-evaluations.pdf", "data": "audited-evaluations-data.json", "source": "plot_audited_evaluations.py", "independent_review": "audited-evaluations-independent-review.json", "scope": "Exp4, Exp5 written policies and all four Exp6 budgets 0/10/25/50; overall replication remains in progress" }, "account_usage_limit": "Remaining Codex-driven conversations cannot continue until allowance is available; independent Spark benchmarks continue. No credential/account bypass attempted." }